CALL (718) 557-9821

People always say the worst things tend to happen when you least expect them, and they were probably talking about auto lock problems. Whether it’s a lost key, a broken one or any other ill-fated event you’ve just happened to come across, you need to get going. 

Do you call the dealership, or do you call your local auto locksmiths in Brooklyn? Here’s how you could be potentially saving hundreds of dollars by going to an auto locksmith instead. 

Auto Locksmiths Vs Dealerships

Say you were to replace a basic transponder key. The dealership would charge you anywhere between $200 to $400, whereas your local auto locksmith would do the same for $100. 

The same goes for a key fob: $500 at the dealership compared to $300 at the locksmith. Why is that? 

Dealerships aren’t exactly trying to rip you off, well, mostly, their prices are high because of legitimate reasons. Since dealerships only use OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) parts, which they mark up 2 to 3 times the wholesale cost. They’ve also got several overhead costs to tend to. Between massive buildings, sales staffs and administrative costs, they wouldn’t get left with much if they low-balled you. 

The question you’re all thinking now is, what do auto locksmiths do differently? 

Here’s what auto locksmiths in Brooklyn offer:

  • Mobile service: They come to you. They’ll meet you wherever your car is. This alone saves you $100-$250 in towing fees.
  • Lower overhead: No massive dealership building, showroom, or commissioned sales staff to maintain. Just a van full of equipment and a skilled technician who knows what they’re doing.
  • Competitive pricing: Locksmiths compete for your business. They know you can call three different locksmiths and get quotes, which is why they keep prices reasonable.

When Would You Actually Need a Dealership?

At this point, we probably sound a little biased. So we’ll give credit where credit is due. 

Dealerships might be your best option if: 

  • You’ve lost all keys to a brand new car. Security systems are getting better than before, and we can only imagine what 2026 is going to bring in terms of that. In case your local auto locksmith hasn’t caught up yet, calling a dealership might be your best bet. 
  • Your car is under warranty, and you’ve got a failing key fob. In this situation, the dealership might replace it for you for free. 
  • Your car model has known problems with the keys, then dealerships should ideally cover all costs for repair. 
  • You’re buying or leasing a car already, so getting an extra key made is the obvious choice. 

For everything else under the roof, your local locksmith is the best option. 

How to Find a Good Auto Locksmith

Okay, but how do you even begin to find an auto locksmith you can trust, especially when every other claims to be one? 

We thought you’d never ask. 

Here are some non-negotiable factors to look for: 

  • Licensing and insurance: Locksmiths should be licensed, especially if they’re in the Big Apple. Always ask for their license number and verify they’re insured.
  • Mobile service: For car keys, you want someone who comes to you with all their equipment.
  • Upfront pricing: Reputable locksmiths will give you a quote before starting work. If they won’t tell you the price until after they’re done, that’s your cue to walk away. 
  • Reviews and reputation: Check Google reviews, Yelp, anywhere people leave feedback. Look for consistent positive experiences.
  • Experience with your car make: Some locksmiths specialize in certain brands. If you drive a certain car, find someone who works on them regularly.

Also Read: Why You Should Hire a Local Locksmith

Fast, Affordable Car Key Service Could Be Your Reality 

At the end of the day, it’s important to realize that dealerships aren’t scamming you. They’re just expensive because of how they operate. For the vast majority of car key situations, an auto locksmith in Brooklyn will:

  • Save you several hundred, depending on your key type and situation
  • Get you back on the road the same day
  • Come to wherever you are, so you don’t need a tow

The only reason to pay dealership prices is if you genuinely need something only they can provide. Which rarely happens, if we say so ourselves. 

If you’re dealing with a car key problem right now, Instalock Locksmith offers transparent pricing and same-day service. We handle everything from basic key cutting to complex smart key programming for all makes and models.

No surprise fees or paying triple what the job should cost. Your car key situation is already stressful enough. Don’t make it more expensive than it needs to be.

Get in touch with us today!